Digital twin: what it is and how it differs from a simulation

Digital twin

A digital twin is a digital representation of a physical asset, such as a robot or a production line, that stays synchronized with it, so what happens on the asset shows up in the model (ISO 23247-1:2021). Michael Grieves introduced the concept in 2003 as a physical product and a virtual one tied together by data and information.

Fyware's XR glossary, with the source behind each definition.

Where the definition comes from

Digital twin, in Fyware's XR glossary
Tom Klukowski

Tom Klukowski

Fyware Partner · Valcre Marketing

How can we help?

Let's Talk

The definition

A digital twin is a digital representation of a physical asset, such as a robot or a production line, that stays synchronized with it, so what happens on the asset shows up in the model (ISO 23247-1:2021). Michael Grieves introduced the concept in 2003 as a physical product and a virtual one tied together by data and information.

ISO 23247-1:2021, the framework for digital twins in manufacturing, defines the twin as a fit-for-purpose digital representation of an observable manufacturing element, with synchronization between the element and its representation. The standard counts eight kinds of observable element: personnel, equipment, material, process, facility, environment, product and supporting documents. In the United States, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine published their own definition in 2024, built largely on one the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) released in 2020; it asks the twin to be updated with data from its physical counterpart and to inform decisions, and it calls the bidirectional interaction between the virtual and the physical central to the concept. The idea is older than both documents. Grieves recounts in a 2014 white paper that he presented a virtual, digital equivalent of a physical product in 2003, in his executive course on product lifecycle management (PLM) at the University of Michigan, and that he attributes the name Digital Twin to John Vickers of NASA. His model has three parts, and the third is the one that makes it a twin: the connections of data and information that tie the virtual product to the physical one.

The difference from a simulation lies in which way the data flows. A simulation starts from assumptions and computes what should happen. Grieves proposed turning digital factory simulation, which tries to predict how a product will be made, into a digital factory replication that shows how it is actually being made, and the National Academies record it as a finding: a digital twin is more than just simulation and modeling. A twin can run simulations, and ISO 23247 treats simulation and synchronization as separate requirements of the framework, yet it feeds them with what the machine measures. A 3D model is a different thing again. Opening a CAD file at 1:1 scale in a headset, as Hololight Space does, serves a design review, and Grieves describes the 3D models some plants put on terminals next to the work cells as a reference that a person has to connect to the physical part by hand. Fyware's case on a production line in augmented reality for Target Robotics draws the same line: a digital twin is connected to the machine's data and reflects what is happening on it, and what was delivered there was full-scale visualization.

For a buyer, the question that sorts proposals is where the data comes from. ISO 23247 does not prescribe data formats or communication protocols, so each project has to decide which controller or sensor variables enter the twin, how often they refresh, which protocol carries them and who keeps the connection working when the line changes. In Fyware's robot case, the link to the controller was specified over OPC UA, against DIN EN IEC 62541-5 and the VDMA OPC UA for Robotics profile. A proposal without that connection delivers a 3D model or a simulation, and it should say so in writing.

Industrial metaverse is the name Siemens and NVIDIA gave in June 2022 to a partnership to connect Siemens Xcelerator with NVIDIA Omniverse, a platform for 3D design and collaboration, and to pair physics-based digital models from Siemens with AI from NVIDIA. The announcement speaks of digital twins with live performance data and of making immersive simulations easier to reach for companies of all sizes.

How it looks in a project

Fyware's published case on an industrial robot digital twin shows the order in which one gets built. For an Austrian industrial augmented reality company, published unnamed, Fyware built a configurator between 2023 and 2024 that works for any arm: the user picks from two to six axes, types the length of each link in centimeters, and the software solves forward and inverse kinematics with code Fyware wrote. The arm stands at 1:1 scale on the floor where the cell would go, in mixed reality on HoloLens 2, with presets for two robots, the UR5 cobot by Universal Robots and the GP8 by Yaskawa. The data bridge worked over ROS against the Yaskawa simulator and Gazebo, and the controller link was specified over OPC UA. Commissioning on the physical cell, the stage that closes the loop with the machine, never took place: the client entered insolvency in September 2024.

Where the definition comes from

«the connections of data and information that ties the virtual and real products together»

Grieves describes the digital twin as a physical product and a virtual one tied together by data and information, and proposes moving from digital factory simulation to digital factory replication.

Source: Michael Grieves, “Digital Twin: Manufacturing Excellence through Virtual Factory Replication”, white paper, 2014

«an observable manufacturing element with synchronization between the element and its digital representation»

The standard defines the digital twin for manufacturing as a fit-for-purpose digital representation of an observable manufacturing element, synchronized with that element.

Source: ISO 23247-1:2021, Automation systems and integration. Digital twin framework for manufacturing. Part 1: Overview and general principles, clause 3.2.3

«bidirectional interaction between the virtual and the physical is central to the digital twin»

The National Academies define a digital twin as a virtual representation that is dynamically updated with data from its physical twin and informs decisions, and call the two-way interaction central; the definition builds on one the AIAA published in 2020.

Source: National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, “Foundational Research Gaps and Future Directions for Digital Twins”, The National Academies Press, 2024, chapter 2, p. 22, DOI 10.17226/26894

«to enable the industrial metaverse and increase use of AI-driven digital twin technology»

Siemens and NVIDIA announced in 2022 a partnership to enable the industrial metaverse and expand the use of digital twins by connecting Siemens Xcelerator and NVIDIA Omniverse.

Source: Siemens AG, “Siemens and NVIDIA to enable industrial metaverse”, press release, Munich, June 29, 2022

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a digital twin and a simulation?

A simulation computes what should happen from assumptions; a digital twin receives what is happening on the machine and stays synchronized with it. A twin can still run simulations, for example to test a change before it reaches the line, but it runs them on operating data. The National Academies' 2024 report states it as a finding: a digital twin is more than just simulation and modeling.

What are examples of digital twins in manufacturing?

ISO 23247-1 lists seven applications in manufacturing: control while the process runs, off-line analytics, predictive maintenance, equipment health checks, engineering design, production control and video surveillance. Its introduction adds that a twin helps detect anomalies in manufacturing processes, and that it monitors its element by constantly updating the relevant operational and environmental data.

What is a digital twin in construction?

It is the building information model (BIM) connected to the building's operating data, so that it reflects the state of the asset; without that data, the BIM is a design and construction model. ISO 23247-1 notes that in building and construction, digital twins may be modeled with the ISO 16739 series, the Industry Foundation Classes (IFC), which ISO describes as an open international standard for BIM data.

Let's talk about your plant

Tell us what you want to solve in your plant. Fyware designs extended reality around the equipment and constraints of your operation, and builds it to grow from a pilot to the whole site.

Tom KlukowskiTom Klukowski, Fyware Partner · Valcre Marketing We reply in under 24 business hours, with scope, timeline and investment range.

In the meeting you see the simulator running and what it would take to bring it to your plant, with scenarios adapted to your layout. And if you need to sell it internally, this page is your presentation: share it with your team.